On our site, we covered a few articles to keep our audience up to date with what institutional investors or Wall Street Landlords are doing in different markets in order to gain different perspectives when it comes down to real estate investing. As a matter of fact, only a few months ago, many Wall Street landlords were acquiring properties across multiple rental markets extremely aggressively (comparing to retail market). However, as of now, things have changed.
The phenomenon of institutional homebuyers rapidly offloading properties has sparked interest and intrigue, particularly in certain regional pockets across the United States. While the general trend among major institutional landlords hasn’t resulted in an overflow of housing inventory, exceptions like VineBrook Homes have captured attention with their brisk selling activities.
What is This Wall Street Landlord doing exactly?
In a recent analysis conducted by Parcl Labs, a startup renowned for its expertise in residential real estate databases and analytics, VineBrook Homes emerged as a significant player in the selling spree, actively shedding a substantial portion of its property portfolio at a remarkable pace. In specific ZIP codes, VineBrook Homes stands out, accounting for a noteworthy proportion of resale listings, such as in Milwaukee’s 53218 ZIP code, where it claims a staggering 31% of properties currently on the market.
What distinguishes VineBrook’s selling strategy in these regions is not just the volume but also the pricing adjustments made. Reports from Parcl Labs indicate that within these ZIP codes where VineBrook is prevalent, they’ve significantly marked down many listings. For instance, in Milwaukee’s 53218 ZIP code, where VineBrook holds ownership over 31% of resale listings, a substantial 86% of these listings underwent price modifications, resulting in a typical unit experiencing a 17% reduction in price.
How about their competitors?
In stark contrast to the purchasing trend of giants like American Homes 4 Rent and Invitation Homes, VineBrook Homes Trust has been consistently reducing its portfolio, marking a noteworthy shift from its rapid expansion during the Pandemic Housing Boom era. Notably, VineBrook Homes Trust trimmed its portfolio by 858 homes in Q3 2023, following a reduction of 524 homes in the previous quarter. This retreat from acquisition signifies a strategic shift influenced by various factors impacting the real estate landscape.
Insights from industry expert Noel Christopher shed light on the intricacies of VineBrook’s situation. Christopher, a prominent figure in the single-family rental (SFR) and build-to-rent space (BTR), emphasizes VineBrook’s overextension due to fluctuating interest rates. He asserts that VineBrook has surpassed its loan DSCR (Debt Service Coverage Ratio) bounds, necessitating actions to align with liquidity requirements. The options facing VineBrook boil down to raising additional capital or liquidating assets. Christopher contends that despite the urgency to sell, VineBrook stands to secure optimal returns given the current market conditions.
So... Why's This Direction?
The financial strains plaguing VineBrook, highlighted in their admission of inadequate liquid capital to meet impending debt obligations, mirror a broader challenge faced by various SFR operators. Christopher affirms that VineBrook’s situation, while noteworthy, isn’t unique, pointing out that numerous operators grapple with similar circumstances but might not publicly disclose these challenges. The dynamics of selling single-family homes individually, as opposed to bulk sales, offer these entities a feasible avenue to meet liquidity requirements amid market fluctuations.
The localized impact of VineBrook’s selling strategy extends to areas like the 45211 ZIP code near Cincinnati, where a significant volume of properties is being divested. This move follows legal tensions initiated by the city of Cincinnati earlier in the year, citing VineBrook’s extensive property ownership and a history of code violations as grounds for legal action. Mayor Aftab Pureval’s stern stance against neglectful property management underscores the conflict between investors and local authorities striving to safeguard residents’ interests.
Amidst these developments, VineBrook’s sales predominantly consist of more affordable entry-level homes, aligning with their strategic market positioning. This deliberate focus on a specific segment becomes evident, as illustrated by VineBrook’s preferences highlighted in their July 2023 investor presentation.
Regions like Jackson, Miss.; Pittsburgh; Milwaukee; St. Louis; and Columbia, S.C., have witnessed a surge in VineBrook’s property listings for sale, signifying a widespread geographical impact of their divestment strategy.
What's The Lessons Here?
VineBrook Home is indeed of the biggest institutional investors out there with thousands of rental homes across the United States as we all can see. And in order to get to that point, we would imagine the research and operational budget they have as a fund. However, rapid expansion sometimes has its own downfalls.
Though some of consequences they are facing right now can be avoided, a few particular challenges are absolutely impossible to predict, especially when it comes down to the shifts in local economy, migration pattern, etc. Therefore, as real estate investors, we must always think 5-10 steps ahead by actively evaluating our assets and strategizing on what’s the next buying and selling moves. Having the right personnel, team members, and a realistic financial forecast with the right amounts of liquidity in place is always a good first step to build a long-lasting rental portfolio.
In Conclusion
VineBrook’s scenario serves as a compelling case study illuminating the complex interplay between institutional investors, evolving market conditions, and regulatory challenges within the real estate landscape. Amidst these fluctuations, the fate of VineBrook Homes stands as a testament to the adaptive strategies necessitated by the ever-changing dynamics of the real estate sector.
As a forever-student, I recently found myself spending significant amount of time studying what institutional investors are doing as they have spent millions and even billions of dollars on researching, acquiring, and strategizing on how to maximize their profits and expand their market coverages. By understanding what they are doing exactly and understanding their thoughts process, mom-and-pop investors like ourselves may learn a thing or two to, at least, avoid some costly mistakes these major investors made in the past.
If you are interested in learning and reading more about this topic, feel free to reach out to our team for more articles like this one at info@chadvorealestate.com
Have a Topic in mind?
Let us know by filling out the form below or contact us here and we will be more than happy to dive deep in future blogs